GTA 6 Has a 99 From Critics and a 5.6 From Players: What Is Actually Going On
Quick Answer
Critics gave GTA 6 a 99 on Metacritic, tying the highest score the site has ever recorded for a video game. Players opened at roughly 5.1 and the user score has moved between about 4.9 and 5.6 in the days since launch. The gap is not one audience being right and the other wrong. It is three different things being measured at once: genuine technical complaints about bugs and frame rate, a coordinated wave of zero-score ratings from people who state they have not played the game, and objections to the game’s content that have nothing to do with how it runs.
Scores in this article were checked on 22 November 2026. The user score is actively moving and Metacritic has removed review-bombing campaigns in the past, so expect it to change.
Key Points
- Critic score: 99 from 152 reviews, tied for the highest ever on Metacritic
- User score opened around 5.1 and has ranged roughly 4.9 to 5.6 since
- Negative ratings appeared before the game was even publicly playable
- Metacritic does not require proof of ownership to post a user rating
- Legitimate complaints centre on bugs, uneven frame rates and the 30fps cap
- The game still took 3.79 billion dollars in day-one sales
The numbers, and why they keep changing
On the PS5 page, GTA 6 holds a Metascore of 99 built from 152 critic reviews. That is the highest tier Metacritic has, and it ties the 1998 Nintendo 64 release of Ocarina of Time for the best-reviewed game the site has ever listed.
The user score is a different picture and a moving one. It opened in the low fives when Metacritic unlocked user ratings, and depending on which day and which outlet you read, it has been reported at 4.9, 5.1, 5.2, 5.4, 5.5 and 5.6. One snapshot on 21 November put it at 5.5 from 34,804 user ratings, against the 99 from critics. By the following day other trackers had it at 5.6 as more ratings came in.
That volatility matters, because any single number you see quoted is a photograph of a score that is still being argued over. Anyone writing that GTA 6 “has a 5.6” is describing one moment.
Why the gap is this wide
It is tempting to pick a side here, and most coverage does. The more useful reading is that the two scores are measuring different populations answering different questions.
A critic score is roughly 150 people who were given the game early, played a substantial portion of it under embargo, and were writing an assessment of the whole work. A user score is tens of thousands of people who can submit a number in ten seconds, for any reason, with no requirement to demonstrate they have played a minute of it.
Those are not two verdicts on the same thing. They are a considered review average and an open poll, and open polls on culturally loaded releases behave the way open polls do.
The complaints that are real
It would be lazy to write the whole user score off, because a substantial share of the negative ratings are pointing at things that genuinely exist and that reviewers also noted.
Performance. The 30fps cap is the single most cited technical objection, and it is a legitimate thing to be annoyed about. The game targets 30fps on every console including the PS5 Pro, with no performance mode anywhere, and the reasoning behind that decision is more defensible than Rockstar’s brief public explanation made it sound. But a player who spent nine hundred dollars on a Pro and got the same frame rate as a base console is not being unreasonable in feeling short-changed.
Bugs and stability. Hard crashes, consoles powering off mid-session and lost save progress all appeared in volume in the first week. These are real and they are also the category most likely to be patched, and in the meantime most of them have known workarounds.
Frame rate consistency. Separate from the 30fps cap, dips below it in the densest parts of Vice City drew complaints, particularly on Xbox Series S where the game spends much of its time in the mid-20s. The GTA 6 performance on every console, compared is genuinely uneven.
If the user score were made up only of these complaints, it would be a useful signal and worth taking seriously.
The complaints that are something else
It is not made up only of those, and this is where the number stops being a reliable read on the game.
Negative ratings were being submitted before GTA 6 was publicly available, which briefly dragged the score down to 6.5 while nobody outside the press could have finished it. Outlets reviewing the user section found it flooded with reviews from people stating they had not played the game. Others reported ratings cast explicitly as retaliation, including one reviewer who awarded a four while calling the game excellent, scoring it to counterbalance what they saw as inflated praise elsewhere.
A further portion of the negative reviews raise objections to the game’s story content, its characters and its perceived politics rather than its technical state. Those are opinions people are entitled to hold and to express, and this article is not going to adjudicate them. The relevant point for anyone reading the score as a buying signal is narrower: a rating given for a game’s politics is not telling you whether the game works, runs well, or is worth your money, which is what most people checking a user score are trying to find out.
Metacritic has removed organised review-bombing campaigns before, and it allows anyone to rate without verifying ownership. Both facts are worth holding in mind before treating the current figure as settled.
Does any of it actually matter?
Commercially, no, and the numbers are not close. GTA 6 took 3.79 billion dollars in day-one retail sales, the largest entertainment launch in any medium, having already sold 32.5 million units before release. A mixed user score has had no visible effect on that.
For the series’ reputation, it is a footnote. Review bombing has hit most large releases of the last decade and the scores typically drift back toward the middle once the organised wave passes and ordinary players who actually finished the game start rating it.
Where it does matter is to the individual trying to decide whether to spend eighty dollars, who looks at a 5.6 and reasonably concludes something is badly wrong. That person is being misinformed, and not in the direction the number suggests.
What to actually use instead
If you are deciding whether to buy, neither number is what you want.
The critic score tells you the game is exceptionally well made, which it is, but it was written by people who did not pay for it and who were playing before the launch-week technical problems surfaced. The user score tells you a culture-war argument is happening. Neither answers your question.
What answers your question is the specific stuff: the frame rate on the console you own, whether your drive has 210GB free, whether the bugs that are being reported affect the version you would be playing. Those are checkable facts rather than aggregate sentiment, and they are the things that will determine whether you enjoy the game or spend your first evening troubleshooting it.
Final Verdict
The honest summary is that GTA 6 is an outstanding game with a genuine technical problem and a user score that has been captured by an argument mostly unrelated to either.
Take the 99 as evidence the game is excellent and the performance complaints as evidence it is not flawless on current hardware. Take the 5.6 as evidence of nothing much at all, at least until Metacritic finishes sorting out which of those tens of thousands of ratings came from people who played it.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is GTA 6’s user score on Metacritic?
It opened around 5.1 and has been reported between roughly 4.9 and 5.6 in the days after launch, against a critic score of 99. The figure is still moving, so treat any single number as a snapshot.
Why is GTA 6 being review bombed?
A mix of reasons. Some ratings cite real technical issues such as bugs and the 30fps cap. Others came from people who stated they had not played the game, some were cast as retaliation against high critic scores, and others object to the game’s content and perceived politics.
Is the 99 Metacritic score real?
Yes. It is built from 152 critic reviews and ties Ocarina of Time for the highest Metascore ever recorded for a game. Note that Ocarina’s 99 came from 22 reviews, so GTA 6’s is drawn from a far larger sample.
Can anyone post a Metacritic user review?
Yes. Metacritic does not require proof that you own or have played a game before submitting a rating, which is the central reason user scores are vulnerable to organised campaigns.
Will GTA 6’s user score recover?
Possibly. Metacritic has removed review-bombing campaigns in the past, and scores on other heavily bombed releases have tended to drift upward once the organised wave passes.
Should I trust the critic score or the user score?
Neither, on its own, if you are deciding whether to buy. Check the specifics that apply to you: the frame rate on your console, whether you have 210GB of free storage, and which launch bugs are still outstanding.